It's new column time again. This week, we muck about with the past along with Marillion, Michael Roe and Quiet Company. All three have revisited older recordings, and all three have found ways to make new art out of old material. I liked all three of these albums, more than I'm liking the new series of Doctor Who, which I also discuss this week.
As usual, stop by the main site to read the column, then head back here to leave a comment.
Thursday, April 25, 2013
Monday, April 22, 2013
Frank Zappa Buyer's Guide #14: Just Another Band From L.A.
In an alternate universe, the
Flo and Eddie incarnation of the Mothers continued well beyond 1971. There’s
clear evidence, both in the Fillmore East
album and the 200 Motels sessions,
that Zappa was having a great time with this band, and in particular the two
gregarious master improvisers out front. There’s no indication that the
material was running out, and the Vaudeville act that the Mothers live show had
become was legendary.
But that’s an alternate
universe. In this one, a crazed fan pushed Zappa off a stage at the Rainbow
Theater in London in December 1971, nearly killing him. Zappa suffered multiple
fractures, head trauma and a crushed larynx, which led to his voice dropping
considerably. It took him almost a year to heal to the point where he could
tour again, and by that time, the rest of the Flo and Eddie Mothers had moved
on.
Which leaves live album Just Another Band From L.A. as the swan
song from this particular band. When it was recorded, in August 1971 at the
Pauley Pavilion in Los Angeles, it was by no means intended to serve as the
final document of these Mothers. But when it was released, in March 1972, Zappa
was still in a wheelchair, and this phase of his career was over. That gives Just Another Band a sort of poignance –
or, it would, if this record were not such a bawdy, raucous affair.
In August 1971, 200 Motels had yet to darken movie
screens across the country, and the Mothers were still playing material from
Zappa’s “life on the road” songbook. But the composer was evidently eager to
move beyond this – Just Another Band
contains no tunes about groupies, tour buses, mud sharks or vibrating beds.
Those songs were all played during the same show, but for this collection,
Zappa chose compositions that showed the ongoing evolution of his work with this
particular band.
The most important track here
is the first, the 25-minute “Billy the Mountain.” In many ways, it’s the
ultimate Flo and Eddie song. It’s a constantly evolving spoof of rock operas,
not limited to the fact that it’s an opera about a guy made of rock. As such,
it’s Zappa’s first real stab at a programmatic piece, a technique he would
perfect a few years later with “The Adventures of Greggery Peccary.”
There’s certainly a classical
influence on this piece, with its repeated and reinterpreted motifs. Billy gets
a six-note theme to himself, and his wife Ethel gets a 12-note interpolation of
that theme. These melodies appear at the beginning of the piece, and crop up
throughout, becoming musical shorthand for the main characters. “Billy the
Mountain” is clearly meticulously arranged, honed over dozens of live
performances.
And yet, it sounds like a
free-flowing comedy routine, in the way that only the most practiced routines
can. “Billy the Mountain” tells the story of the title character, one of the
Rocky Mountains, and his wife Ethel, a tree growing off of his shoulder. The
tale begins when Billy finally gets his royalty check for all of the postcards
he’s posed for. He and Ethel decide to go to New York on a vacation, walking
across the country – and destroying anything in their path. Along the way,
Billy is drafted into the army, and he ignores the summons.
To stop Billy, the U.S.
government taps superhero Studebaker Hoch, named after the Studebaker Silver
Hawk automobile. Studebaker Hoch rubs himself down with Aunt Jemima syrup to
attract an army of flies, who lift him off the ground to talk with Billy. This
doesn’t go well, and Billy’s laughter causes an avalanche, sending Hoch to his
(possible) death below. The moral of the story? “A mountain is something you
don’t want to fuck with, don’t fuck with Billy, don’t fuck around.”
This is all great fun, and
the band sells it as an ever-unfolding series of gags. Many of them are Los
Angeles in-jokes, but just as many – including a poke at Jerry Lewis and an
interpolation of the Tonight Show
theme – are universally funny. The nimble band – Zappa, Jim Pons, Aynsley
Dunbar, Ian Underwood and Don Preston – shifts from section to section without
betraying any indication of how difficult it all is to play. While some of the
jokes go on longer than they should, “Billy the Mountain” as a whole never
drags.
“Billy” takes up the entire
original first side of this album, and the second side feels like a strong
series of four bonus tracks. Three of them are barely worth discussing – you
get the Flo and Eddie reinterpretations of “Call Any Vegetable” and “Dog
Breath,” both arranged with new focus on the vocals, and another extended
in-joke, “Eddie Are You Kidding,” about Los Angeles store Zachary All Clothing
and its advertisements starring its owner, Edward Nalbandian. The reinventions
are interesting, and “Eddie” is a pleasant trifle.
But you also get “Magdalena,”
one of the few cases in which Zappa’s envelope-pushing led him into the realm
of the truly tasteless. The song itself is an intricate skipping soul-punk
number, but it’s sung from the point of view of a man trying to rape his young
daughter. It’s an outgrowth of the “what would you do, daddy” section of “Brown
Shoes Don’t Make It” extended to uncomfortable lengths: “Magdalena, don’t you
tease me like this, right in the hallway with your blouse and your tits, if
your mommy ever finds us like this, she’ll call a lawyer, oh how mom will be
pissed…”
Zappa does include one verse
to show that he’s on Magdalena’s side: “The girl turned around and said ‘go eat
shit’ and ran on down the hall, right on, Magdalena.” But then he allows Kaylan
to improvise the father’s twisted pleas for the final minutes of the song, and
it’s squirm-inducing. “I’d like to take you in the closet and take off all your
clothes until you are virtually stark raving nude, spread mayonnaise and
Kaopectate all over your body…” “I wanna take off your little training bra, I’m
gonna take off your maroon hot pants…” “We can make love all night long, no one
will ever know…”
Zappa defended lyrics like
this by saying he was reporting on the vile attitudes and practices of
Americans, without condoning them. But the song doesn’t make that clear,
spending most of its time voicing the father’s point of view in a jaunty way.
This would be a problem plaguing Zappa’s lyrics from this point forward – he’s
never certain of the line between condemning behavior and celebrating it.
“Magdalena” is a tremendous song, but its tone is disconcerting.
Overlook that, though, and Just Another Band From L.A. is a barrel
of fun. It is arguably the most successful document of the Flo and Eddie era,
proof that the concept could have carried on, if not for one insane fan. At one
point during “Call Any Vegetable,” Zappa announced to the audience that the
theme for that night’s show was “It is so fucking great to be alive.” He
couldn’t have known when he said them just how resonant those words would be.
Rating:
Worthy.
Which version to buy: Broken record time, but the best bet is the 2012
remaster from Zappa/Universal. It reverts to the original analog master – the
1990s Ryko CDs use a duller and darker digital master – and the sound is bright
and glorious.
Next week: Waka/Jawaka.
Thursday, April 18, 2013
New Column: Things Are Getting Scary
And we're back. After two weeks off to deal with a dead cat and a horrible illness, I've finally written a new column that I like. I hope you like it too.
This week, I've reviewed new albums from the Flaming Lips (above) and the Knife as part of a discussion about music designed to disturb and unnerve. As always, click on over to read it, and head back here to leave me a comment. It's good to be back.
This week, I've reviewed new albums from the Flaming Lips (above) and the Knife as part of a discussion about music designed to disturb and unnerve. As always, click on over to read it, and head back here to leave me a comment. It's good to be back.
Monday, April 15, 2013
Frank Zappa Buyer's Guide #13: 200 Motels
It’s an unfortunate truth
that as a filmmaker, Frank Zappa was a terrific musician.
This lack of affinity for the
art form never stopped him, however. While in later years he would stick to
concert films, like the extensive Baby
Snakes, he definitely harbored the ambition early on to create a movie for
theatrical release. He tried it in the 1960s with Uncle Meat, but shelved the idea when he ran out of money. But his
second stab at filmmaking, the nigh-unwatchable 200 Motels, made it all the way to the multiplexes. (Where, of
course, it died a sputtering death.)
While the movie has not made
the leap to the digital era, the soundtrack has, and it’s one of Zappa’s most
difficult and complex works. United Artists gave Zappa $650,000 to make the
film, and most of that money went toward hiring the London Philharmonic
Orchestra to finally flesh out some of the composer’s more intricate melodies.
In many ways, Zappa’s entire musical career to this point led to the meshing of
rock and orchestral music that makes up the bulk of 200 Motels.
The prior Flo and Eddie-era
Mothers albums were certainly a prelude to this monstrosity. Zappa was intent
on capturing the experience of touring, both musically and visually, and the
raunchy material on both Chunga’s Revenge
and Fillmore East – June 1971 paved
the way for the themes of 200 Motels.
It includes surreal tales of backwater towns, an encounter with “Lonesome
Cowboy Burt” in a country bar, a ripped-from-life retelling of bassist Jeff
Simmons’ departure from the band, and many songs about groupies.
In fact, Zappa had never
before combined his low and high arts as thoroughly as he did on 200 Motels. In Flo and Eddie, Zappa had
found gleeful accomplices – they could sing anything put in front of them, and
would happily spout Zappa’s increasingly perverse lyrics. And with the London
Philharmonic, Zappa could explore the fuller sounds he had been after. So what
we have here is mainly sophomoric humor set to impossibly beautiful (and very
difficult) orchestration, with rock band flourishes. A true mixing of highbrow
and lowbrow.
Zappa was unhappy with the
performances of his session players, but imagine you are a member of the
prestigious London Philharmonic, and you are given a piece called “Penis
Dimension.” Now, imagine you are unable to properly play a piece called “Penis
Dimension,” because it’s remarkably intricate, and you have been given very
little time to learn it. Orchestral players had a tendency to underestimate
Zappa as a composer, and Zappa had a tendency to overestimate his players’
willingness to pursue perfection at union scale wages.
If there are issues with the
performances on 200 Motels, they’re
likely recognizable only to the composer himself. The score is in parts
breathtaking – the opening “Semi-Fraudulent Direct From Hollywood Overture”
uses lines from “Little House I Used to Live In,” “Dance of the Just Plain
Folks” is a dark instrumental piece that changes shape every few seconds, and
“Janet’s Big Dance Number” is claustrophobic and eerie.
“Janet’s” is part of a suite
of songs on the first disc that describe groupies getting ready to meet and
have sex with touring musicians, and they’re perfect examples of the clash of
low and high arts. The orchestra provides interludes while the rock band
thunders in for three linked vocal pieces. In “Half a Dozen Provocative
Squats,” Flo and Eddie provide a lament for the sexually frustrated woman: “The
last guy to do her got in and got soft, a sad but typical case.”
“Shove It Right In” picks up
the story, finding groupies on the prowl: “At least there’s sort of a choice
there, 20 or 30 at times there have been, somewhat desirable boys there,
dressed really spiffy with long hair, looking for girls they can shove it right
in…” The powerful orchestral piece “Lucy’s Seduction of a Bored Violinist and
Postlude” concludes the tale. It’s like a concerto of smuttiness.
Does this work? At times the
scatological humor overpowers the orchestral score, easily the more interesting
of the two elements. The Mothers – the same lineup that made Fillmore East – take
the spotlight a few times, most notably on the single “Magic Fingers,” and the
bawdier material works better with blistering guitars. But there’s no denying
the genuine beauty of the melodies in “What Will This Evening Bring Me This
Morning,” for example.
And then there is “Dental
Hygiene Dilemma,” a song that achieves almost Inception levels of recursion. Zappa was a compulsive
documentarian, and had a habit of recording his band members at all times – in their
hotel rooms, during cab rides, anywhere he could place a microphone. That’s how
he managed to record Simmons grousing about the “comedy music” Zappa kept
making him play, and musing about leaving the band and starting a more serious
solo career.
Zappa decided, when writing
the script for 200 Motels, to include
this secretly taped conversation as a scene, with Simmons playing himself. He
did not, however, run this idea past Simmons – the first the bassist heard of
it was at a read-through of the script. And as the band was intoning the lines
about Simmons quitting the band, he did just that, getting up and walking out.
(Even this conversation was recorded by Zappa, and appears on Playground Psychotics. Confused yet?)
Without Simmons (he was
replaced in the film by actor Martin Lickert), Zappa switched gears – he created
“Dental Hygiene Dilemma,” a psychodrama about Simmons’ exit, accompanied in the
film by animation. Flo and Eddie play Simmons and his conscience, arguing over
whether Simmons is “too heavy” to remain in Zappa’s “comedy band.” The music is
remarkably complex, and Volman and Kaylan attack their roles with relish. It’s
one of the most striking pieces on the album, and only the start of Zappa’s
obsession with secretly recording his band members.
After a set of shorter, more
dissonant orchestral numbers, 200 Motels concludes with “Strictly Genteel,” an
11-minute summation of Zappa’s genre-crashing ambitions. The song is built on
one of Zappa’s most straightforward and stately melodies – it is clearly the
grand finale – and it gives equal weight to the London Philharmonic and the
Mothers. It begins with strings and Theodore Bikel singing about terrible
English food, and ends with cascading guitars and drums and Volman ranting
about Zappa’s all-encompassing control. It’s the blending of low and high art,
writ large.
200 Motels
has only briefly been available since its release in 1971, and because of that,
it’s seen as a curiosity in Zappa’s catalog. In reality, it’s a landmark, an
experimental melding of Zappa’s most ambitious and most earthbound tendencies,
soaring and complex music used to convey his most inconsequential and
smut-filled lyrics. In later years, Zappa would tend to separate his sleazy
rock from his orchestral scores – he would rarely combine them like this again.
200 Motels is not entirely
successful, nor is it clear what it would sound like if it were entirely
successful. It’s an entity unto itself, an island even in Zappa’s vast sea of
music. It’s a one-of-a-kind work, and in some ways, that’s a good thing.
Rating:
Worthy.
Which version to buy: Well, if you want a CD copy, there’s only one choice:
MGM and Ryko teamed up to release this, finally, in 1997. It’s out of print
now, of course, and it could use a thorough remastering. But since it’s the
only option, buy it if you can find it.
Next week: Just
Another Band From L.A.
Tuesday, April 9, 2013
Frank Zappa Buyer's Guide #12: Fillmore East - June 1971
-->
Chunga’s Revenge was really just the prelude. This live album, released two months
after it was recorded, was the true opening salvo of the Flo and Eddie era. It
remains one of the most controversial releases of Frank Zappa’s long career,
signaling a turn away from the biting social commentary of Mothers albums past
and a turn towards a more scatological form of observational humor.
That’s an academic way of
putting it. The truth is that Fillmore
East – June 1971 is one long dick joke. It is part of Zappa’s attempts to capture
the life of a rock band on the road, and was recorded after filming had wrapped
for the similarly themed Mothers movie, 200
Motels. The material on Fillmore East
– and it is almost entirely new – is an expansion of the groupie routines from 200 Motels, in which Zappa
“immortalized” the apparently numerous women in each town desperate to have sex
with his band members.
In Flo and Eddie (Mark Volman
and Howard Kaylan, previously with the Turtles), Zappa had found
more-than-willing accomplices. Though Zappa still led and conducted his band on
stage, Flo and Eddie were the frontmen, gleefully leading the group through one
routine after another. They’re remarkably strong singers, the finest Zappa had
yet employed, but they also excelled at improvised comedy. The groupie
material, which makes up 80 percent of this album, grew and evolved each night
of the tour, Flo and Eddie encouraged to keep pushing boundaries.
The sleazy subject matter was
matched by Zappa’s new, pared-down Mothers, featuring himself on guitar,
drummer Aynsley Dunbar, bassist Jim Pons (also from the Turtles), and
keyboardists Ian Underwood and Bob Harris. Gone is the sense of the band as
rock orchestra – the new Mothers were a nimble rock band, drawing from blues
more than any of Zappa’s other influences. Zappa’s guitar playing had taken on
a particularly raw and nasty tone, which fit this new material perfectly.
Anyone picking up Fillmore East – June 1971 would know
right away that this was a different kind of Mothers album. The front cover is
plain white, with the words “The Mothers” and the album title scrawled in
pencil. The recording quality is similarly unvarnished – this sounds like a
high-end bootleg, and given how particular Zappa was about sound quality, this
can only be intentional. This is a steamy, down-and-dirty kind of record.
After a splendid,
stripped-down version of “The Little House I Used to Live In,” which shows off
Underwood’s chops, Zappa gets things started with “The Mud Shark,” a retelling
of a story originally relayed by members of the Vanilla Fudge. The tale
involves the Edgewater Inn in Seattle, where guests can rent fishing poles and
cast them out their room windows into the ocean below. It includes the titular
mud shark, a young groupie and a movie camera. You can probably guess the rest.
This leads into the groupie
material. Volman and Kaylan role play as the groupies on “What Kind of Girl Do
You Think We Are,” and as the virile musician, here called “Bwana Dik.” “I am
endowed beyond your wildest Clearasil-spattered fantasies,” Volman sings,
before declaring that “all groupies must bow down in the sacred presence of the
latex solar beef.”
Things get even raunchier in
“Do You Like My New Car,” seven minutes of Volman pretending to be a groupie
hoping to seduce Kaylan. Here it becomes clear that groupies, in Zappa’s world,
are only interested in having sex with musicians who have a song in the charts
“with a bullet.” (Each time that phrase is uttered, the band punctuates it with
a quick explosion.) At one point, Volman’s character is referred to as a
“voluptuous Manhattan island clit,” and sex with soda bottles and donkeys is
explored.
So what makes this
album-length dick joke worth listening to? For one, it’s an epic dick joke,
with an epic punchline – the groupies demand to hear the band’s hit song (with
a bullet!), and the group launches into the Turtles smash “Happy Together.”
It’s such a metatextual left turn that it’s completely unexpected, even if you
know the song is coming. It almost makes all of the buildup worth it, which
could be a sexual metaphor in and of itself. Volman and Kaylan absolutely sell
this material, too – it’s hard not to grin along with them, even when they’re
talking about shoving an enchilada up a donkey’s ass.
But for another, the band is
tremendous. Underwood, Pons and Dunbar form a lean rock machine, and Zappa’s
dirty guitar playing is perfectly attuned to them. The band slays the new
arrangement of “Little House,” and Zappa’s fiery solos on both parts of “Willie
the Pimp” are superb. If you focus on the frontmen during “Bwana Dik” and
“Latex Solar Beef,” you may miss how complex these songs are. And the encores,
including a take on “Peaches En Regalia” driven by wordless vocals and a slam
through Mothers single “Tears Began to Fall,” are terrific. There are precious
few opportunities in Zappa’s catalog to hear this particular band, which is a
shame.
Some see the change in tone
on Fillmore East – June 1971 as a
shame as well. This album marks a turning point – rarely again would Zappa
engage in social criticism as pointed as that on We’re Only In It for the Money without also indulging these baser
instincts. Joe’s Garage, for example,
is rightly cited as one of Zappa’s finest works – it’s about a world in which
music has been outlawed, and about a man who imagines guitar solos in the air.
But it’s also about sex with household appliances, anal rape in prison, and
receiving blowjobs from robots.
While that lyrical direction
arguably began with “Brown Shoes Don’t Make It,” this is the album on which
Zappa doubles down, and chooses that path for the rest of his career. He seemed
to enjoy people suggesting that his sexual humor cheapened his musical work,
and for the rest of his career, he would not compromise either one. In some
ways, the Flo and Eddie band was his way of testing the waters, and as we’ll
see over the next two entries, he pushed the bounds of good taste repeatedly.
Zappa would soon give us the likes of “Bobby Brown Goes Down” and “He’s So
Gay,” and that journey truly began here.
Despite all that, Fillmore East is a fun little record,
and the “Happy Together” moment will bring a smile, if nothing else will. The
Flo and Eddie years remain the most argued-over and passionately defended era
of Zappa’s career. If you want to find out why, you need to hear this.
Rating:
Essential.
Which version to buy: Again, the Zappa family came through with the 2012
Zappa/UME remaster. The new release reverts to the original 1971 analog mix,
ignoring the master Zappa made in the 1980s. Good thing, too – that master
added tons of digital reverb and eliminated “Willie the Pimp Part Two.” The new
version restores the original (still raw) mix, and the missing track, making it
the definitive CD release of this album.
Next week: 200
Motels.
Sunday, April 7, 2013
Late Column: Can't Beat a Record Store
Hello, all. Apologies for the lack of updates this week - been dealing with a sick cat, as well as some other life stresses. I finally got this week's column up, though, in which I praise my local record store, Kiss the Sky, and review three new-to-me bands: Little Green Cars (above), Young Dreams and And So I Watch You From Afar. They're all quite good. Read all about it here, then head back here to leave a comment, if you like.
I'll be on track next week. Expect Zappa on Monday, a column on Wednesday, and whatever else I can get to in between. Thanks for your patience.
I'll be on track next week. Expect Zappa on Monday, a column on Wednesday, and whatever else I can get to in between. Thanks for your patience.
Monday, April 1, 2013
Frank Zappa Buyer's Guide #11: Chunga's Revenge
Chunga’s Revenge is an important album in the Frank Zappa catalog. It introduced the second incarnation of the Mothers of Invention, featuring ex-Turtles Howard Kaylan and Mark Volman on vocals. As such, audiences looked to it to answer the question of where Zappa intended to go next, after dissolving the original Mothers. It also followed hot on the heels of two odds-and-sods collections from the prior band, and was his first “new” statement since Hot Rats.
So why does Chunga’s sound more like a haphazard
compilation than either of its immediate predecessors? Frankly, this album is a
bit of a mess. It culls five studio tracks from the new Mothers and places them
on the same piece of wax as two instrumental jams, one long bit of live
insanity, a brief percussion piece and a holdover from the Hot Rats sessions, all of which were performed with different
groups of musicians.
Chunga’s,
released in October of 1970 (Zappa’s third record of the year), is not the
confident step forward it perhaps should have been. It presents a slightly
confused vision, one that Zappa and his band would hone for their next release,
and spends a little too long making you wait to hear the new direction. However,
if you consider every album and every song part of a single unified work, as
Zappa did, this album starts to make more sense. Why shouldn’t these pieces
exist together? Only marketing concerns would keep them apart.
Taken in that light, Zappa
seems to be easing his audience in over the first side of this album. Zappa’s
new Mothers consist of drummer Aynsley Dunbar, bassist Jeff Simmons, pianist
Ian Underwood and brass and keys player George Duke. But the real draw here is
Volman and Kaylan, who – for contract reasons – have adopted the names The
Phlorescent Leech and Eddie. That’s Flo and Eddie for short, and after making
their mark with the Mothers, the pair would go on to use those names for their
own act.
That act was pure comedy. Flo
and Eddie were both strong singers, but Zappa was more interested in their
ability to deliver smutty laughs, which they did with abandon. Flo and Eddie
fronted the Mothers for three years and four albums, and it remains the most
controversial period in Zappa’s history. With them aboard, Zappa seemed intent
on chronicling “life on the road,” telling sordid tales of groupies and sex in
odd places (and sometimes, as we’ll hear on the next album, with weird animal
species). Flo and Eddie were not just willing participants, they attacked these
roles with relish. There was no line they wouldn’t cross, and this left Zappa
with no boundaries either.
We get the barest hints of
that on Chunga’s Revenge, the most
reserved of the Flo and Eddie albums. But there’s no doubt the new lineup of
the band is the main attraction, which naturally means that Zappa makes you
wait until side two to hear what they really sound like. The first half of the
record kicks off with “Transylvania Boogie,” an absolutely incendiary jam
between Zappa, Underwood, Dunbar and bassist Max Bennett. It’s unclear how much
of this was planned out beforehand, but the fluid tempo shifts sound organic
and remarkable.
Zappa himself takes the lead
on “Road Ladies,” the first and most obvious “life on the road” song. It’s a
standard blues about the healing powers of groupies, the first piece of what
would become the Mothers movie, 200
Motels. That leads into the jazzy instrumental Hot Rats castoff “Twenty
Small Cigars” and a nine-minute mosaic of live improvisations – mostly pounding
drums and yelping – called “The Nancy and Mary Music.” That’s all of side one.
Thankfully, the full power of
Mothers Mark II is brought to bear on the second side. The four glossy studio
tracks featuring Flo and Eddie are all powerhouses, debuting a new
guitar-driven rock sound designed for 1970s radio. “Tell Me You Love Me” is a
prototypical rock single, one of Zappa’s first, and it shows off just how
strong his new vocalists could be. Zappa’s guitar has rarely sounded this
fierce – if not for “Transylvania Boogie,” it would be the most ferocious thing
here.
Zappa takes on the USO in
“Would You Go All the Way,” suggesting that the entertainment provided for our
troops goes beyond a little theatrical show, and begins his long-standing feud with
unions on “Rudy Wants to Buy Yez a Drink.” (Zappa had several bad experiences
with musicians unions, frustrated at the players’ unwillingness to stay late or
put in extra effort, and extrapolated that into an “all unions are bad”
mindset.) Both of those songs make use of Duke’s impeccable brass playing.
In between them, we get the
title track, a classic Zappa instrumental. It’s lilting bass lines and
memorable melody lead into a wah-wah sax solo from Underwood and a typically
terrific guitar solo from Zappa. The same can’t be said of “The Clap,” a
percussion piece that sounds more scattered and improvised than usual.
Zappa concludes things on an
uncharacteristically sweet note, with one of his most heartfelt pieces. He
would go on to record “Sharleena” five times in total between 1970 and 1984,
and it’s deserving of the honor – it’s a lovely little tune, perhaps the only
one of his originals that approaches the timeless status of the ‘50s balladry
he adored. The Chunga’s Revenge
version is delightfully straightforward, Volman and Kaylan nailing the vocal.
It’s a simple piece, worlds away from the complex orchestrations that make up
the rest of the Flo and Eddie years, but an effective one.
It caps off an album that
points both forward and backward without much confidence. Chunga’s Revenge follows a period of intense musicianship and
social criticism, and precedes an era of even more intense musicianship and
intricate dick jokes. It has a tendency to get lost and forgotten, despite the
handful of gems it contains, and that’s down to its slight and confused nature.
As the opening salvo of Mothers Mark II, Chunga’s
Revenge isn’t nearly as strong as it should be.
Rating:
Worthy.
Which version to get: This is going to sound like a broken record, but the
2012 Zappa/UME reissue is the one you want. Unlike previous CD editions, this
one returns to the original 1970 vinyl master, and makes it even brighter and
fuller. If nothing else, this album at least sounds fantastic.
Next week: Fillmore
East, June 1971.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






